Skip to content
AstroWellnessLinda Kirschenbaum
Menu
← Back to Weekly Torah

weekly torah

Vayishlach — Wrestling with What We Cannot Escape

Jacob’s return to Esau, his night of wrestling, and the losses that follow invite reflection on fear, unfinished growth, suffering, and the courage to recognize and take the next true step.

Linda Kirschenbaum · 11 min read

Torah portion: Vayishlach

Have you ever found yourself having to confront something you thought you had left behind years ago? Perhaps a relationship, a fear, an unresolved conflict, or even a part of yourself you believed you had already overcome. You have moved on, built a life, gained experience, and become a different person. Yet somehow, life brings you back to the very thing you once ran away from. This is where we find Jacob in this week's Torah portion, Vayishlach.

Twenty years have passed since Jacob fled his brother Esau, who had threatened to kill him after losing their father's blessing. Jacob has spent those years working for Lavan, marrying, raising children, and building considerable wealth. Now God has instructed him to return to the land of his fathers, which means he will have to face the brother he left behind. He knows he must return, but he has no idea whether Esau still carries the same anger he did twenty years earlier.

Jacob sends messengers ahead of him, hoping to establish peaceful contact, but they return with alarming news: Esau is approaching with four hundred men. The Torah tells us that Jacob becomes greatly afraid and distressed. Rashi, drawing on Genesis Rabbah, explains these two reactions separately. Jacob is afraid that he might be killed, but he is also distressed by the possibility that he may have to kill others while defending himself. This is a man who understands that protecting his family may require actions he desperately hopes to avoid.

And so Jacob prepares. He divides his people into two camps, sends gifts ahead to appease Esau, and prays for God's protection. The Sefat Emet, drawing on a teaching from his grandfather, the Chiddushei HaRim, offers an interesting explanation of Jacob's distress. Jacob was troubled by the very fact that he was afraid, despite having received God's promise of protection. I find this remarkably human because we can know that we are capable of facing something and still experience fear when the moment arrives. Sometimes the frustration we feel toward our own fear becomes another struggle altogether.

Later that night, after sending his family and possessions across the Jabbok River, Jacob finds himself alone. The Talmud, in Chullin 91a, explains that he had returned to retrieve small vessels he had left behind. Another commentator, Rashbam, offers a very different interpretation: Jacob intended to escape by another route to avoid meeting Esau, and the mysterious figure who wrestled with him prevented him from fleeing. According to this reading, Jacob was being held in place so that he could experience the fulfillment of God's promise. I find this interpretation fascinating because sometimes we can recognize that something needs to be confronted, yet when the moment arrives, every instinct tells us to leave.

Jacob wrestles throughout the night with a mysterious figure whom rabbinic tradition identifies as Esau's guardian angel. The struggle continues until dawn, and although the opponent injures Jacob's hip, he cannot overcome him. Jacob refuses to release him without receiving a blessing, and the figure gives him a new name: Israel, because he has struggled with divine and human beings and prevailed. The man who had spent twenty years away from his brother has now endured an entire night of wrestling, and he emerges with a different identity.

The Sefat Emet explains that the names Jacob and Israel correspond to the dimensions of body and soul. A person must refine the body so that the power of the soul can become manifest through it. This interpretation interests me because Jacob's spiritual transformation takes place through an intensely physical encounter. His body participates in the struggle, and he emerges limping. It reminds us that caring for our physical existence is part of our spiritual responsibility, even though physical health or strength can never serve as a measurement of someone's righteousness.

There is also a deeper Kabbalistic understanding of Jacob's two names. In the teachings of the Arizal, Jacob and Israel represent different levels of spiritual consciousness, associated respectively with Rachel and Leah. Rachel corresponds to the revealed world and Malchut, while Leah is associated with a more concealed dimension connected to the higher understanding of Binah. These are intricate symbolic relationships, but the central idea is accessible: spiritual development expands our capacity to perceive and understand reality.

Interestingly, Jacob's original name never disappears. Abraham, once renamed, is no longer called Abram, yet the Torah continues to alternate between Jacob and Israel. The Talmud explains in Berakhot 13a that Israel becomes the primary name while Jacob remains secondary. I wonder whether this reflects something we all experience: a genuine transformation can take place while certain aspects of our former selves remain with us. The Sefat Emet also acknowledges that some dimensions of rectification cannot reach their ultimate completion until a future time. Perhaps spiritual growth includes learning to live responsibly with what remains unfinished.

After the wrestling, Jacob names the place Peniel, meaning the face of God, because he has encountered a divine being face to face and survived. The following morning, he finally meets Esau, and something extraordinary happens. Esau runs toward him, embraces him, kisses him, and they weep together. Jacob then tells his brother that seeing his face is like seeing the face of God, because Esau has received him favorably. Consider what has happened: Jacob spent the night wrestling with a divine representative of the brother he feared, and the next morning he finds himself embraced by that very brother.

There is another beautiful distinction in their conversation. Jacob offers Esau gifts, which Esau initially refuses, explaining, Yesh li rav — I have plenty. Jacob insists, saying, Yesh li kol — I have everything. Rashi interprets Jacob's words as an expression of having everything necessary, while Esau speaks of abundance beyond his needs. The difference brings to mind Pirkei Avot's question: Who is rich? The person who is happy with his portion. Perhaps having everything has less to do with the quantity of our possessions than with our ability to recognize what we already have.

One might think that after this extraordinary reconciliation Jacob would finally enjoy a period of peace. After all, he has survived Lavan, wrestled an angel, confronted Esau, and returned to the land of his fathers. But apparently, Jacob's life has other plans.

This reminds me of the Cage the Elephant song Ain't No Rest for the Wicked. I sometimes joke with my children that I must be wicked because there is never any rest. Of course, Jacob is far from wicked, but his life certainly illustrates how even the righteous may experience one challenge after another. He settles near Shechem, and soon his daughter Dinah is abducted and violated by Shechem, the son of Hamor. After Shechem expresses his desire to marry her, Jacob's sons negotiate a condition requiring the men of the city to undergo circumcision. On the third day, while the men are recovering, Shimon and Levi attack the city, killing its males and bringing Dinah home. Jacob is deeply troubled by their actions and fears the consequences for his household.

And then comes another terrible loss. Rachel dies giving birth to Benjamin, completing the twelve tribes. Rashi, citing Midrash, connects her death to Jacob's earlier declaration that whoever had stolen Lavan's household idols should not live, unaware that Rachel herself had taken them. The Zohar offers another mystical explanation, connecting her departure with the completion of the twelve tribes and the establishment of the Shechinah among them. These traditions approach the tragedy differently, and neither changes the human reality that Jacob loses the woman he loved so deeply.

All of this brings me to the Book of Job, which I have been reading recently. Job is described as a righteous man, yet he loses his possessions, his children, and his health. His friends initially sit beside him in silence for seven days, offering a form of companionship that requires no explanations. Then they begin arguing that his suffering must have resulted from something he did wrong. They are so convinced that they understand divine justice that they cannot recognize the suffering of the person sitting in front of them. Eventually, God speaks to Job from a whirlwind, challenging the limits of human understanding, and afterward addresses Eliphaz, rebuking him and his companions for their words.

What makes this especially interesting is that Jewish tradition sometimes connects Job's Eliphaz with Eliphaz, the son of Esau, although this identification is not explicit in the biblical text. Rashi recounts that Esau's son pursued Jacob with instructions to kill him but spared his life because he had been raised in Isaac's household, taking Jacob's possessions instead. Another Talmudic tradition suggests that Job lived during Jacob's lifetime and married Dinah. These connections are not universally accepted, but they demonstrate how the sages saw relationships between stories that appear in different books of the Tanakh.

The final chapter of Vayishlach lists Esau's descendants, including Eliphaz and Amalek. In Sanhedrin 99b, the Talmud tells a remarkable story about Timna, who wanted to join Abraham's family but was rejected. She subsequently became Eliphaz's concubine and gave birth to Amalek, whose descendants would bring tremendous suffering to Israel. The sages ask why such suffering emerged and answer that Timna should not have been rejected when she sought to join them. I find this extraordinary because the teaching requires us to examine the responsibility of our own ancestors, even when discussing someone who later becomes an enemy.

This brings us back to the assumption that good people should experience good circumstances and wicked people should suffer. The Book of Job challenges that assumption directly. So does Jacob's life. Spiritual greatness does not guarantee an absence of suffering, and material success does not establish righteousness. Our sages discuss reward in this world and in the world to come, but we should be careful about assuming that we can identify someone's spiritual standing from their circumstances.

I keep returning to the image of Jacob walking away from Peniel as the sun rises. He has prevailed, received a new name, and survived a remarkable encounter, yet he is limping, and he still has a brother to face. His life will continue to bring circumstances he cannot predict or control. What he can do is recognize the responsibility before him and choose how to respond.

Perhaps this is what Vayishlach asks us to consider. We cannot always know why certain experiences enter our lives, how long a difficulty will last, or what another person will choose to do. We can prepare, seek understanding, acknowledge our fear, and remain attentive to what the circumstances actually require. Sometimes that means confronting something we once escaped, and sometimes it means accepting that an answer is beyond our present understanding.

I recognize the next true step and act with courage.

That is something I can practice, even when I cannot see what comes afterward.

---

References and Sources

1. Genesis 32:4–33:17 — Jacob's fear, preparations, wrestling, naming of Peniel, and reconciliation with Esau.

2. Rashi on Genesis 32:8; Genesis Rabbah 76:2 — Jacob's fear of being killed and distress over potentially killing others.

3. Sefat Emet, Vayishlach 5649 (1888), second discourse — Jacob's distress over his own fear.

4. Chullin 91a; Rashi on Genesis 32:25 — Jacob returning for small vessels and the angel identified with Esau.

5. Rashbam on Genesis 32:25 — Jacob's intention to flee and the angel preventing his escape.

6. Sefat Emet, Vayishlach 5636 (1875), first discourse — Jacob and Israel as dimensions of body and soul.

7. Berakhot 13a — Israel becomes Jacob's primary name without eliminating the original.

8. Sefat Emet, Vayishlach, discourse discussing the remaining unrectified sinew — The limits of complete rectification before the future redemption.

9. Teachings of the Arizal, Sha'ar HaPesukim, Vayetzei — The spiritual correspondences of Jacob, Israel, Rachel, and Leah.

10. Genesis 33:9–11; Rashi on Genesis 33:11 — Yesh li rav and yesh li kol.

11. Pirkei Avot 4:1 — Who is rich? One who is content with one's portion.

12. Genesis 34 — Dinah, Shechem, Shimon, and Levi.

13. Genesis 31:32; Rashi; Genesis Rabbah 74:9 — Jacob's declaration concerning the stolen idols and its connection to Rachel's death.

14. Zohar, Vayetzei, sections 247–248 — Rachel's death, Benjamin's birth, and the completion of the twelve tribes.

15. Job 2:11–13; 38–42 — Job's friends, God's response, and the rebuke addressed to Eliphaz.

16. Rashi on Genesis 29:11 — Eliphaz pursuing Jacob but sparing his life.

17. Bava Batra 15b — The opinion associating Job's lifetime with Jacob and identifying Dinah as his wife.

18. Genesis 36:10–12; Sanhedrin 99b — Eliphaz, Timna, Amalek, and the rabbinic criticism of Timna's rejection.

The connections between these narratives, together with the practical reflections on fear, spiritual development, responsibility, and courage, represent my own interpretation unless attributed to a specific source above.