Skip to content
AstroWellnessLinda Kirschenbaum
Menu
← Back to Weekly Torah

weekly torah

Finding Meaning | Vayetzei

Surely God Was Here, and I Didn't Know It

Jacob’s realization at Bethel, his years with Laban, and the lives of Rachel and Leah invite us to consider where God may be present within hardship, longing, practical effort, and the future we cannot yet see.

Linda Kirschenbaum · 14 min read

Torah portion: Vayetzei

There is a moment in Parashat Vayetzei that moves me so deeply that every time I read it, I feel like crying. It comes at the very beginning of the portion, when Jacob wakes from his famous dream of angels ascending and descending a ladder between heaven and earth.

He opens his eyes and says:

“Surely the Lord is in this place, and I did not know it.” (Genesis 28:16)

Of all the extraordinary things Jacob witnesses in that dream, it is his realization upon waking that stays with me.

If God is everywhere, why are we so frequently unaware of His presence?

There is a difference between knowing intellectually that God is everywhere and actually perceiving Him in our everyday lives.

Jacob grew up in the home of Isaac and Rebecca. He knew about God, the promises made to Abraham, and the spiritual inheritance of his family. Yet here he stands, astonished. Something he had known throughout his life had suddenly become something he experienced.

And look at the circumstances in which this happens.

Jacob is fleeing his brother Esau. According to a Midrashic tradition, Esau had sent his son Eliphaz to kill Jacob. Eliphaz caught up with his uncle but couldn't bring himself to murder him. He was caught between obeying his father and following his conscience.

Jacob offered him a solution: take everything I have, since a poor man is considered as one who is dead.

And so Jacob continues his journey with nothing.

He is far from home, uncertain of what awaits him, and, as the song says, battered and broke.

He gathers stones to rest his head upon, falls asleep, dreams, and wakes up with the realization that God was there all along.

I find this extraordinary because I recognize something of myself in his circumstances.

I have experienced financial uncertainty more times than I care to remember. I mean literally arriving at the end of the month with bills piled up, barely sliding into home, wondering how on earth everything is going to get paid.

And when we find ourselves in these situations, where does our mind go?

Usually, straight into the future.

We imagine the moment when the difficulty will finally be over. We want the bills paid, the problem resolved, the relationship repaired, the uncertainty gone. We become so consumed with escaping our present circumstances that we barely notice where we are.

But what if the present experience is building the foundation for the future we are so desperately pursuing?

A difficult experience is not necessarily evidence that we have lost our way. Sometimes it may be the very environment in which our tikkun, our personal work of correction and growth, becomes possible.

The problem is that we don't particularly enjoy going through the process.

We say, yes, yes, I know God is here, but could He please be over there, in the future I want, instead of here, in the present I'm trying to run away from?

And this brings me back to Ayeka, God's question to Adam in the Garden of Eden.

Where are you?

Where is my attention right now? Am I actually present, or am I so busy imagining my escape that I have stopped paying attention to what life is asking of me?

Pirkei Avot 4:1 asks who is mighty and answers that it is the person who conquers his own inclination.

I think recognizing the urge to escape, without automatically obeying it, is one way of putting that teaching into practice.

Of course, knowing this doesn't mean we suddenly enjoy hardship. I certainly don't. But perhaps we can stop long enough to recognize that a difficult moment doesn't necessarily mean God has abandoned us.

And sometimes, we may not recognize what a particular experience has contributed to our lives until many years later.

Which brings us to Leah.

The Woman Jacob Never Intended to Marry

After arriving in Haran, Jacob meets Rachel and falls in love with her. He agrees to work seven years for her father, Laban, in exchange for her hand in marriage.

Seven years!

The Torah tells us that those years seemed like only a few days to Jacob because of his love for Rachel.

But Laban has other plans.

On the wedding night, he substitutes his older daughter Leah for Rachel, and Jacob discovers the deception the following morning.

Imagine working seven years for something you deeply desire, only to wake up and discover that you've been cheated.

Jacob eventually marries Rachel as well, agreeing to work another seven years for Laban.

But I want to jump forward for a moment, thousands of years forward, because something remarkable emerges from the marriage Jacob never intended.

Leah becomes the mother of Levi, from whom the priestly line of Israel descends, and Yehudah, the ancestor of King David and the royal dynasty associated with the future redemption of the Jewish people.

These two lineages become central to Jewish religious and historical identity.

Jacob couldn't possibly have understood all those consequences on the morning he discovered Leah beside him.

He was dealing with the immediate reality of Laban's deception, the disappointment, and the obligation to work another seven years.

I wonder whether, with the benefit of seeing what emerged from that marriage, Jacob might have looked back on that morning and repeated the words he spoke after his dream.

Surely God was there, and I didn't know it.

This doesn't excuse Laban's dishonesty. It simply reminds me how little of the future we can see while we're living through the present.

Leah, Rachel, and the Things We Cannot Make Someone Give Us

Leah's story moves me for entirely different reasons.

She is married to a man who loves her sister more than he loves her. And through the names she gives her children, we catch glimpses of the pain she carries.

When Reuben is born, she speaks of God seeing her suffering and expresses the hope that her husband will now love her.

With Simeon, she speaks of God hearing that she is unloved.

When Levi arrives, she hopes that Jacob will finally become attached to her.

Then comes Yehudah, and Leah expresses gratitude to God.

For a moment, her words seem to move beyond the longing for her husband's affection.

But years later, after the birth of her sixth son, Zebulun, she again expresses the hope that Jacob will honor her.

And I find myself wondering about this woman.

How much did Leah try to prove her value through the children she gave Jacob? How often did she measure herself through the affection she hoped to receive from him?

She was already valuable. The future priesthood and royal dynasty would emerge from her descendants. But did she recognize her own worth independently of her husband's affection?

Did Leah ever come to see herself as enough?

I don't know.

Perhaps that is a question each of us should answer for ourselves.

Rachel, meanwhile, has a very different experience.

She has Jacob's love, yet she cannot conceive.

According to the tradition Rashi brings from the Talmud, Jacob and Rachel had arranged secret signs to protect themselves against Laban's dishonesty. When Rachel realized her father intended to substitute Leah, she gave her sister those signs to spare her the humiliation of being exposed.

Rachel was willing to delay her own marriage to protect her sister.

Later, the Torah tells us that Reuben found dudaim, plants traditionally associated with fertility, and brought them to his mother Leah.

Rachel wanted them and offered Leah a night with Jacob in exchange.

But the story unfolds in a fascinating way. Leah conceives again, eventually bearing two additional sons, while Rachel's long-awaited pregnancy comes later, when she gives birth to Joseph.

Here are two sisters, each longing for something the other possesses.

Leah has the children Rachel desperately wants. Rachel has the love Leah spends years longing to receive.

And both women make choices, take action, negotiate, sacrifice, and struggle with circumstances they cannot entirely control.

I couldn't help thinking of the Rolling Stones' song You Can't Always Get What You Want.

But who gets to decide what we need?

And how often do we become so focused on what someone else has that we fail to recognize the value of what is already present in our own lives?

Their relationship is complicated, and I don't think we need to pretend otherwise.

Yet something happens toward the end of the portion that I find particularly meaningful.

When the Family Has to Pull Together

Jacob spends twenty years working for Laban: fourteen for his marriages and another six building his own flocks.

During those final years, he negotiates an agreement under which certain spotted, streaked, and dark-colored animals will become his wages.

Laban, being Laban, immediately complicates matters by removing animals that meet those descriptions and separating them from the remaining flock.

Jacob responds by placing peeled branches in the watering troughs where the animals mate. The Torah describes his methods and the subsequent growth of his flocks.

The commentators examine the relationship between Jacob's actions and the divine assistance responsible for his prosperity.

And here is where I find myself asking a question.

How do we know that the ideas we receive, the opportunities we recognize, and the actions we take aren't themselves part of the way God answers our prayers?

We sometimes speak about prayer as though divine assistance and human effort occupy separate worlds.

But Jacob prayed, worked, negotiated, observed his animals, made decisions, and kept going.

Could God's help have been present in his intelligence, his resourcefulness, and his ability to recognize an opportunity?

I ask because most of us are ordinary people trying to fulfill our responsibilities. We have families to support, bills to pay, and circumstances that demand practical decisions.

We cannot simply sit around waiting for miracles.

Jacob's story makes me consider the possibility that divine assistance may sometimes become recognizable through the very actions we are required to take.

Eventually, Jacob realizes that Laban's attitude toward him has changed. God instructs him to return to the land of his fathers and promises to be with him.

But Jacob has a large household now. Leaving is no longer as simple as packing a bag and walking away.

He calls Rachel and Leah into the field, explains what has been happening with their father, and tells them about God's instruction.

And this is one of my favorite moments in the entire portion.

After all the rivalry, disappointment, jealousy, and conflict between these two women, they respond to Jacob together.

They recognize how their father has treated them and their family. They understand that the time has come to leave.

Whatever differences existed between them, they now have a common responsibility.

They need to pull the family wagon in the same direction.

I find that enormously practical.

Families don't always agree. Spouses, siblings, and relatives carry their own disappointments, expectations, and grievances. But sometimes circumstances require us to recognize that our shared responsibility is more important than the argument we've been having.

Rachel and Leah don't need to become identical people or erase everything that happened between them.

They need to recognize what the moment requires.

And they do.

Have I Ever Abandoned You?

There is a personal experience I want to share because it is one of the reasons Jacob's realization at the beginning of Vayetzei means so much to me.

In June 2019, my family was moving from Florida to California.

We had already sent our furniture across the country, and our house in Florida was empty. While our belongings made the journey from the East Coast to the West Coast, we decided to spend a week in Panama.

I was terrified.

We were leaving behind the life I had spent years building in Florida, and I was afraid we were heading straight back into the financial circumstances we had struggled with during an earlier period in California.

We were changing our location without fundamentally changing how we earned our income.

I couldn't stop imagining everything going wrong.

One day, while we were in Panama, I drank a small amount of mushroom tea and went for a walk in the rainforest.

I remember observing the little mud crabs, the vegetation, the movement of the branches, and the trees surrounding me.

And then I experienced something that has stayed with me ever since.

I heard what felt like a voice inside my head, although somehow it seemed to be coming from one of the trees.

It asked:

“Have I ever abandoned you?”

I cannot tell you where that voice came from. I can only tell you what I experienced and how deeply that question affected me.

Because when I considered it, I couldn't think of a time when I had truly been abandoned.

There had been tremendous difficulties. There had been periods when I had no idea how we were going to manage financially. There had been fear, uncertainty, exhaustion, and circumstances I desperately wanted to escape.

But somehow, we had continued moving forward.

And that question stayed with me throughout the first years in Huntington Beach, which turned out to be some of our hardest.

Whenever I found myself overwhelmed by circumstances, I remembered that afternoon in the rainforest.

Have I ever abandoned you?

It didn't pay the bills. It didn't remove the uncertainty or eliminate the responsibilities waiting for me.

But it changed something about how I experienced those moments.

I could recognize that the hardship I was facing wasn't necessarily evidence that I had been left alone.

And when I read Jacob's words, I understand something of what that realization can feel like.

At the beginning of Vayetzei, Jacob wakes up and discovers that God was present in a place where he had not recognized Him.

Toward the end, God tells him to return to his homeland and assures him that He will be with him.

Between those two moments are twenty years of labor, complicated marriages, children, deception, financial negotiations, disappointment, and extraordinary growth.

Twenty years of living.

And that is what I love so much about this portion.

We don't need to reach the spiritual level of Jacob to recognize something meaningful in his experience.

We can begin with the lives we're actually living.

The next time we're overwhelmed by a problem, frightened about the future, disappointed in a relationship, or desperate for a particular outcome, perhaps we can remember Ayeka.

Where am I right now?

What is this moment asking of me?

And am I paying enough attention to recognize the help, the possibilities, and the responsibilities already in front of me?

I still worry about money. I still become impatient when life doesn't move in the direction I want. And I still have moments when I would much rather be somewhere else, preferably somewhere with good waves and absolutely nothing demanding my attention.

But I return to Jacob's words again and again.

“Surely the Lord is in this place, and I did not know it.”

Perhaps He was here all along.

Perhaps I was simply too busy trying to get somewhere else to notice.

Sources and References

Biblical and rabbinic passages referenced in the essay. Personal reflections and interpretive questions are the author’s own.

1. Genesis 3:9. God’s question to Adam, “Where are you?” (Ayeka). Biblical text

2. Genesis 28:10–22. Jacob’s journey, ladder dream, and recognition of God’s presence (especially 28:16). Biblical text

3. Genesis 29:1–35. Jacob’s meeting Rachel, service to Laban, marriages, and Leah’s first four sons. Biblical text

4. Genesis 30:1–43. Rachel’s infertility, the dudaim exchange, Leah’s later children, Joseph’s birth, and Jacob’s flock agreement. Biblical text

5. Genesis 31:1–55. God’s instruction to return, Rachel and Leah’s joint response (31:14–16), departure, and confrontation with Laban. Biblical text

6. Rashi on Genesis 29:11. The tradition of Eliphaz pursuing Jacob and taking his possessions; Rashi cites Genesis Rabbah 70:12 and Nedarim 64b. Original text and translation

7. Rashi on Genesis 29:25; Babylonian Talmud, Megillah 13b. Rachel’s handing over of the private signs to Leah to spare her humiliation. Original text and translation

8. Pirkei Avot 4:1. Ben Zoma’s teaching: strength is mastery of one’s inclination. Original text and translation

9. Numbers 3:5–10; 1 Chronicles 2:1–15. The Levitical priestly line and the line from Judah to David. Biblical text